Zan Zanzib

Vladimir Ermolaev,

Good evening. I'm in good spirits... Thank you.

Thank you

Vladimir Ermolaev,

Zan Zanzib, In my opinion, dear Zanzib, the author's version is preferable... The form is stronger... Thank you.

Thank you, Vladimir, I mean what I feel,
but I won't object if everyone sticks to their opinions.

I like the composition,
I'd like to crop it a bit on the left to about 4:5.

Mostra ritaglio

..and the pioneers will pass by - salute to Kibalchish!

Alla Shevchenko,

Zan Zanzib, Thank you for your feedback!

You're welcome

p.s. ..there are too many flowers, but if they were a little less common, it would be more interesting..

The still life has potential, but in my opinion it's not quite finished yet.
It lacks asymmetry, at least one detail that connects the two, either through color, texture, shape, or a connection between top and bottom.

Galina Balakhonova,

Ghosted Metro:)))

Regarding the metro and ghosts, anyone curious about the topic would be interested in watching Titarenko

..yes, I was thinking about it, but I was holding the photo in my hand..))

Interesting, but I imagine completely different pictures for this line of Tsuren..)

Galina Balakhonova,

Zan Zanzib, Perhaps, but then it would be a different angle. The sun is behind me…

I understand,
there are tripods, and also small clamps that can be attached to handrails, railings, benches, branches, all sorts of metal things...
They're small, lightweight, and easy to carry in your pocket.

Interesting picture, interesting effect)
NMV, if it weren't for your shadow (and no one else's)
it would be even better...

I don't know about the whisper, but I can clearly see a Sukhoi or a new-generation MiG in a sharp turn.

Alexander Chumakov,

You're photographing potatoes again. These are cosmic potatoes on a cosmic scale. And the shadow of the accountant Votruba.

Are you talking about Jonah Tikhy?

Vadim Bogdanov,

Thank you. Everyone seems tired of people walking endlessly against a backdrop. But at the same time, no one can resist the temptation of seeing the various plays of light and shadow and the person walking against the backdrop. And your hand just reaches out… )))

I have them too, but honestly, I try to restrain myself… it doesn't always work.

A good photo,
I'm a little tired of endless people walking against the backdrop of something,
but this shot stands out, more interesting than many – the background is rich,
with a variety of echoes and details, light accents and reflections

..but then along came a frog, orange-bellied,
orange-bellied, and ate the blacksmith..)

Seryozha Tuman,

And? Is the child missing a thumb on his right hand?

The thumb is visible, it's in the dark near the cheek, but there are six fingers in total.
Better more than less..

Tatyana Karachkova,

Zan Zanzib, why do you come to my page? Go where you find nothing but positivity.

I didn't ask you for advice on where to go...
I don't visit your page, but I do check the discussion feed.
I was drawn to Alexander's comment, as a developing still life artist,
with whom I often exchange opinions.
You can learn and discuss from material you don't like.
I hope you're satisfied with my answer.

Alexander Chumakov,

Zan Zanzib, Agree that in life it often happens like this: someone might like something, and you might just as easily dislike it yourself.

Of course, it's normal for some people to like pork cartilage and for others to like watermelon rind.

Alexander Chumakov,

Food... Drinks... Still life... I really liked your still life, Tatyana! I looked at it with pleasure!

You have an interesting perception, mine is the opposite, only negative.

Gennady Leonidovich,

This European devilry hasn't caught on here, thank God!

Apparently, it hasn't caught on with the authorities either...
Our youth are actively having fun...

Victor Gail,

Zan Zanzib, I imagined the final race of the ex-wives) and a photo finish!!!

Yes!! Many exes now wouldn't even make it halfway, funny..)

I can't comment on the photo as a whole; it looks technical.
I see the last one's mistakes; she's very tense and has dropped her entire foot.
Of the famous ones, I knew Natasha Bochina well; my third wife was also a sprinter.

looks like a woman's nipple..)

Liliya Rodionova,

Zan Zanzib, for me, the bottles and branches created the image of a path in an abandoned garden.

I thought about it and decided that your image is spot on,
only it's not a park, but a small square, squeezed in among old houses.

Zan Zanzib, and the dilapidated house on 7th or 3rd Liliya Street (I also wanted to fantasize – you can't see beyond the letters). That's why Liliya wrote that the glass is opaque.
I liked the still life.

Alexander Chumakov, thank you, Alexander,
for St. Petersburgers, this is an instantly recognizable word, "line" – that's what streets on Vaska have been called since Peter the Great's time.

Zan Zanzib, and for me, the bottles and branches created the image of a path in an abandoned garden.

Liliya Rodionova, of course, all that could be there,
but what about the dilapidated house?..

Overall, I liked it, but there were too many bottles with dark glass; I think clear ones would have looked more interesting.

Liliya Rodionova, thanks, Liliya. I was looking for the feeling of a dark bender ending.
I usually settle for less.

Not a bad view,
it's a shame the cyclist is positioned almost vertically under the lighthouse.

Yulia, you managed to capture an original photo of a familiar place.
Mars and Stozhary are beautiful.

Interesting view,
questionable image processing, poor walking phase.

🙂

It seemed a bit criminal to me, even gloomy, like two corpses with covered faces that haven't been removed from the crime scene yet.
Good work, Maxim.

ripples of space-time, the passage of a gravitational wave.

Zan Zanzib, thanks, I didn't understand, how are we going to cut the branch?

Liliya Rodionova, it's not that important, it's up to your taste and choice,
what's important is that it doesn't "fit in" )

The wall looks great with the stool...
And even though I don't like your eternal bottles, they're perfect here, in my opinion...
How about trimming the top edge of the branch a little?
It'll give you a different feel...

Zan Zanzib, когда я фотографирую стекло, я не описываю жизнь героев, мне интересно показать многогранность стекла(как пропускает свет, свечение стекла, его оттенки и хрупкость), здесь не нужно искать логику в подборе предметов, искать глубокий смысл.

Liliya Rodionova, p.s. и мне кажется, что ты не права, когда говоришь, что без героя,
он всегда присутствует помимо твоей воли, ведь кто-то стоит за кадром,
кто-то сложил эти предметы вместе, кому-то они принадлежат.. просто это не очевидно,
но подспудно зритель воспринимает..

Zan Zanzib, когда я фотографирую стекло, я не описываю жизнь героев, мне интересно показать многогранность стекла(как пропускает свет, свечение стекла, его оттенки и хрупкость), здесь не нужно искать логику в подборе предметов, искать глубокий смысл.

Liliya Rodionova, да, понимаю, я не ищу глубокий смысл, бывает, оно само как-то складывается, а бывает и не складывается.. это невербально, а только ощущения..
вот и разные восприятия )

Zan Zanzib, у меня с тобой слишком различается восприятие натюрморта, я знала, что ты напишешь про перегруз.

Liliya Rodionova, конечно отличается, это ведь нормально..?
мы же составляем натюры, описывающие жизнь разных героев, разного пола, разного характера..
приятно, что ты можешь предугадывать мои чувства и мысли )

симпатичные колючки...
кмк лишние предметы и выглядит слегка натужно..

Very good

Zan Zanzib, very interesting comparison. I didn't even notice. And yet, that's exactly it. However, I think the architects of these buildings didn't know or even hear of the existence of a natural analogue. This is the Bolshoy Anngachak Ridge, and the cathedral is Pila.

Dmitry Shishkin, very few things in the world have humans invented from scratch...
Basically, almost everything, they spied on nature,
selected, reworked, enhanced, transformed, interpreted, combined disparate elements, etc.

What an interesting symmetry there is on the zp...
I've seen many such architectural solutions – a central building, a portico, and two rounded wings on the sides organizing the space in front of it.
The most famous, for example, are the Kazan Cathedral or the Grand Gatchina Palace.

Everything's fine... there's no need to comment...
This tray is very convenient...

Have you tried pulling it over your head? That would be an attempt.

вот она, воот!..)
но это уже не знаменитая, шадровская.. а более поздний "одетый вариант" другого скульптора..)

Знакомая тропа... В этот день мы сделали 35 км. Помнится, на другой стороне ущелья стоял крохотный домик. Но туда пешкой добраться невозможно, только заброска вертолётом. Интересно, сохранился ли он... Вы стартовали от ТЭЦ? Снимок замечательный и спасибо за воспоминания.

Кетова Вера, а вы по прежнему в своём стиле, под чужими фотами всё о себе любимой

хорошее фото, Василий

Тут про настроение, а не про рескость.

Сувлехим Такац, ой, большое спасибо что подсказали.. а то совсем бы потерялся